Skip to main content
Home Whitman College Penrose Library | Arminda Collections

Main menu

  • Home
  • Browse Collections
  • About
  • Login
  1. Home
  2. Honors Theses
  3. Why wouldn’t you just say that? : self-silencing and negation as strategies of the null persona in battered women’s narratives
Title

Why wouldn’t you just say that? : self-silencing and negation as strategies of the null persona in battered women’s narratives

    Item Description
    Limited Access
    The author(s) chose to restrict access to this thesis to current Whitman students, faculty, and staff. Please log in to view it.
    Linked Agent
    Creator (cre): Haer, Satinder
    Advisor (adv): Hanson, Jim
    Department (dpt): Whitman College. Rhetoric Studies
    Date
    December 13, 2013
    Graduation Year
    2014
    Abstract

    This thesis examines the personal narratives of female intimate partner violence survivors. These narratives are used to identify how women blame themselves for entering and staying in abusive relationships, how they minimize their own abuse, and how they are uncertain and dismissive of their experiences. The rhetorical strategies that survivors use to self-blame, minimize, and dismiss their experiences of abuse are labeled as "self-negating" and "self-silencing." Through an analysis of intimate partner related court case transcripts and news articles, I examine how dominant views of intimate partner violence also blame victims, minimize abuse, dismiss, and question the experiences of battered women. Amid this parallel discourse, the women’s personal narratives show that they view themselves in a way that reflects dominant views. They do so even though they are free of the extra-discursive constraints defined by Dana Cloud as social, political, and economic factors that influence a rhetor. Cloud argues that the presence of these social, political, and economic extra-discursive constraints is what forms a "null persona" or a persona that renders the rhetor, him or herself, the irrelevant or negated party through their discourse. By taking into account the implied audience of narratives posted at violenceunsilenced.com, I argue, contrary to Cloud, that the null persona exists even in the absence of extra-discursive constraints. As these women write their narratives, they face no physical threats, economic incentive, or overt social pressure, yet their rhetoric reflects that they are still affected by the dominant views of intimate partner violence. The null persona created by this type of rhetoric has the effect of serving as a strategic tool which forms identification between previous and current victims of IPV.

    Subject
    Discourse ethics -- Society -- Victim blaming
    Persona -- Null persona
    Battered Women -- Psychology -- Domestic assault
    Blaming the victim (Victim blaming) -- Criticism and interpretation
    Domestic violence
    Mass media and crime -- Criticism and interpretation
    Abuse -- Self-negation
    Abuse -- Self-silencing
    Survivors psychology
    Abused women -- Psychology -- Analysis
    Personal narratives
    Women -- Violence against
    Intimate partner violence -- Psychological aspects
    Self-Blame
    Rhetoric
    Academic theses
    Whitman College 2014 -- Dissertation collection -- Rhetoric Studies
    Genre
    Theses
    Extent
    54 pages
    Permanent URL
    http://works.whitman.edu/1252
    Rights
    http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
    Contact Us

    If you have questions about permitted uses of this content, please contact the Arminda administrator: http://works.whitman.edu/contact-arminda

    8114143
    Home Whitman College Penrose Library | Arminda Collections

    Footer menu

    • About
    • Author FAQ
    • Contact Us
    • List of Collections
    • Policies
    • Terms of Use